Gaming Laptop vs Desktop: Which Is Right for You [2023]

Options
Robert_Stark
edited August 2023 in Gaming

You've finally decided to upgrade your gaming hardware; the excitement is palpable. The age-old question arises: gaming laptop or desktop? 

Gaming has evolved, as well as the hardware that powers it. While desktops have long been the go-to choice for serious gamers, gaming laptops' performance and portability have significantly improved. Most gamers can only choose one.  

Our comprehensive guide will help you navigate the gaming laptop vs. desktop conundrum and choose one that best suits your needs. 

Gaming laptops vs. gaming desktops: day-to-day tasks 

While gaming laptops and desktops can handle many of the same tasks, their unique features set them apart. Gaming laptops offer portability, while desktops provide greater customization options. Let's dive into their critical distinctions. 

1) Gaming laptop features: 

  • Built-in display, keyboard, touchpad 
  • Integrated battery for on-the-go gaming 
  • Limited wired connectivity options 
  • Upgradability constraints 

Gaming laptops offer the ultimate convenience for gamers who value mobility. They combine all the essentials into one compact package for an immersive gaming experience. With their built-in display, keyboard, touchpad, battery, and wired/wireless connectivity, gaming laptops are ready to play straight out of the box.

If portability is a top priority, a gaming laptop is your best bet. Lightweight and compact, perfect for AAA gaming wherever you are or working while traveling. But, this mobility comes with a trade-off - limited customization and upgradability.

Gaming laptops deliver performance but often lack the flexibility of desktops. You may be able to upgrade the hard drive and RAM, but other options are generally limited. A gaming laptop could be the perfect fit to balance portability and performance. 

2) Common gaming desktop Features:

  • Separate display, keyboard, and touchpad 
  • No battery, not portable 
  • Extensive wired connectivity 
  • Easy to customize and upgrade 

Desktops offer a different gaming experience. They don't come with the peripherals you need to use, so you must research the right ones and buy them at an additional cost. Since desktops lack a battery, they aren't suited for travel and offer a stationary gaming setup.

However, gaming desktops excel in customization and upgradability. You can invest in better peripherals or upgrade hardware to keep up with new games. The ability to personalize your gaming rig and enhance its performance over time is a significant draw for desktop gamers.

Consider your gaming needs and priorities to decide which is right for you. If you want enhanced mobility, go with a laptop. If you need more power and customization, go with a desktop. If you stream games, even a Chromebook will suffice.

Gaming laptop vs. desktop: performance showdown 

When it comes to performance, the eternal battle between gaming laptops and desktops continues. While it's true that the specs you choose play a significant role in overall performance, desktops generally have an edge. However, modern gaming laptops have made considerable strides to close the gap.

You might expect comparable performance where gaming laptops and desktops boast similar CPUs, GPUs, RAM, and storage. But desktops typically outshine laptops in demanding tasks like:

  • Gaming 
  • Video editing 
  • Machine learning

Thermal constraints can limit laptop GPU and CPU performance. GPUs generate a lot of heat and need substantial cooling systems to dissipate it. Dedicated graphics cards for high-performance gaming are typically large, making it challenging to fit them into laptops.

Laptops' smaller size means compromises are necessary even if the hardware is comparable. Often, laptop GPUs are throttled for thermal control, which affects in-game performance.

With their more extensive chassis and extra fans, desktops benefit from superior cooling and heat dissipation. This advantage allows desktops to push their powerful hardware even further, achieving higher performance levels with overclocking and water-cooling options.

While gaming laptops have evolved to offer impressive performance at high resolutions and settings, running AAA titles like:

  • Cyberpunk 2077 
  • God of War 
  • Call of Duty: Modern Warfare

The best gaming desktops provide a more seamless gaming experience with smoother gameplay and higher frame rates. Due to space limitations, computer hardware performs better in gaming desktops than gaming laptops.

A desktop can handle heavy gaming sessions, but some laptops have weaker processors and graphics cards, making them less capable of playing AAA titles. So, check the specs before purchasing.

Choosing between a gaming laptop and a desktop comes from personal preference and priorities. If mobility and convenience are your top concerns, a gaming laptop may be the ideal choice. But for those who crave the highest performance and customizability, a gaming desktop is the way to go.

Winner: Desktop

Gaming laptop vs. desktop: power consumption 

Laptops are more energy-efficient, consuming 200 to 300 watts, while desktops demand around 500 or more during gameplay. A desktop can add a few hundred dollars to your power bill over its lifespan.

However, some gaming laptops struggle with heat dissipation and are noisier due to their compact design and high-speed fans. While generating more heat overall, desktops benefit from better cooling systems and quieter operation.

If power efficiency and portability are your priorities, a gaming laptop is your best bet. A gaming desktop will be ideal if you prefer quieter gaming with superior heat management. Consider these trade-offs when deciding between the two.

Winner: Laptop 

Gaming laptop vs. desktop: hardware upgrades 

Upgrading gaming laptops is challenging due to their compact design, often with the CPU and GPU soldered onto the motherboard. Generally, you can only swap RAM and storage, while CPU and GPU upgrades are impractical. With gaming desktops, however, hardware upgrades are straightforward thanks to their modular layout.

A gaming desktop is better if hardware upgrades are essential to you. Gaming laptops trade easy upgrades for portability. 

Winner: Desktop

Gaming laptops vs. desktops: storage showdown 

Storage is crucial in ensuring smooth gameplay, as today's AAA games demand ample space. Cyberpunk 2077 requires at least 70 GB.

Laptops have limited room for installing additional HDDs or SSDs, giving gaming desktops the edge with their extra storage bays. However, external storage can be added to gaming laptops when needed.

Gaming desktops typically boast multiple SATA ports—responsible for data transfer between the HDD and the computer—allowing for the installation of extra HDDs or SSDs. While gaming laptops come with reasonably sized SSDs, their compactness and portability can't quite compete with the vast storage capacity offered by gaming desktops.

Winner: Desktop

Gaming laptops vs. desktops: portability showdown 

Gaming laptops take the crown in portability, effortlessly fitting into backpacks. With built-in displays, keyboards, and varying sizes, these all-in-one machines cater to gamers' on-the-go needs without sacrificing performance.

In contrast, desktops are much larger and lack the same convenience. The need for additional peripherals and a monitor means they aren't as travel-friendly, making gaming laptops the clear winner in this match-up.

Winner: Laptop 

Gaming laptops vs. desktops: cost and value 

Regarding cost, gaming desktops generally have a better price-to-performance ratio than gaming laptops. Gaming desktops cost less for the same performance than gaming laptops.

However, on top of the price, you also want a machine that delivers value in two ways:

  • Excellent performance for the price 
  • Long useful life

Gaming laptops excel in portability and convenience, providing an all-in-one gaming solution, albeit often at a higher initial cost. If you value mobility, gaming laptops offer excellent value.

Desktops offer higher performance for the same price. Their modular nature allows for easy upgrades, and you get long-term value through customization and upgradability.

The choice comes down to your priorities: portability (laptops) or upgradability (desktops). 

Winner: Tie

Conclusion 

When it comes to buying a gaming laptop or a desktop, there is no correct answer. One isn't better than the other. Ultimately, the choice depends on your preferences and priorities.

If portability and convenience are essential, a gaming laptop is worth it. However, if customization and upgradability are your top concerns, a gaming desktop might be the better option.

Robert is a Taiwan-based writer and digital marketer at iamrobert design. He has a passion for helping people simplify their lives through tech.

Socials

Stay Up to Date


Get the latest news by subscribing to Acer Corner in Google News.